Fire on Bunker Hill: A 30-Year Fight for Justice

July 29, 2025 • 03:18:59
Fire on Bunker Hill: A 30-Year Fight for Justice
The Murder Tape Khronicles | True Crime Secrets Unveiled
Fire on Bunker Hill: A 30-Year Fight for Justice

Jul 29 2025 | 03:18:59

/

Show Notes

They told Matthew Hoy’s family it was a tragic accident—a car fire after a night of partying. But three decades later, everyone in Shamokin, PA, still whispers about what really happened on Bunker Hill. Fueled by new forensic science, relentless investigation, and a flood of tips unleashed by true crime podcasts, this story unravels the chilling possibility of a murder covered up for 30 years. From burned evidence and blood-soaked car seats to witnesses who lived in fear and a community finally ready to speak, each chapter digs deeper into the secrets of small-town justice gone wrong. With the suspects hiding in plain sight and the internet now demanding answers, the fight for justice isn’t over—and the final twist may still be out there.What would you have done in their shoes?

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Previous Episode
Next Episode

Other Episodes

Episode

January 28, 2026 • 00:12:10
Episode Cover

Murder of Alexis Gabe (California, 2022)

In 2022, 24-year-old Alexis Gabe vanished in California after a recent breakup, triggering a missing-person investigation that quickly revealed troubling inconsistencies and a narrowing...

Listen

Episode 362

December 19, 2025 • 00:15:02
Episode Cover

Murder of Mark Garrity (Oregon, twenty twenty three)

This three chapter limited series reconstructs the killing of Mark Garrity in an Oregon grocery store parking lot after a road rage confrontation spiraled...

Listen

Episode

May 21, 2026 • 00:09:31
Episode Cover

She Called Her Children 'Zombies.' He Buried Them in the Yard.

In late 2019, two children were buried in a backyard in Salem, Idaho. Their mother had classified them as zombies — a label in...

Listen